PopNotes vs American Greetings e-cards

American Greetings sells an annual membership, around $30–36 a year, for unlimited sends from a large catalog of e-cards and print-at-home cards. PopNotes sells single cards at $4.99, each with an original song written about the person it's for. Pick American Greetings for volume and variety; pick PopNotes when one card needs to feel personal.

PopNotesAmerican Greetings
Price$4.99 per card, no subscriptionAnnual membership, around $30–36 a year, with a free trial
Cards you can sendOne per purchase; packs lower the priceUnlimited during membership
What's personalAn original song with their name and your details, plus your messageYour message, and on some designs a photo or name
SongWritten for this card, about this personPre-made music and animations
DeliveryA link for text, WhatsApp, email or DMEmail, text or social
Print optionNo, digital onlyYes, print-at-home cards included
Best forThe cards that matter mostSending lots of cards through the year

American Greetings details checked 18 October 2026 from published membership comparisons. Prices vary by page and promotion; check americangreetings.com for current pricing.

Choose PopNotes if

  • You want a card that couldn't have been sent to anyone else.
  • You only send a handful of cards a year.
  • You want it fast: made in minutes, with no subscription to cancel.

Choose American Greetings if

  • You send cards to a long list of people every year.
  • You want print-at-home cards as well as e-cards.
  • You'd like a big catalog to browse, with scheduling.

What about American Greetings' custom songs?

American Greetings also offers custom songs through a partnership with Songfinch, delivered within about a week at Songfinch pricing. See PopNotes vs Songfinch for how that compares.

Make a card with their song · $4.99